Mailchimp knows your people. It doesn’t know your calendar.
So every week you type the events in by hand. Butter pulls them straight from Planning Center, for the same price you’re paying now.
No card required. Keep Mailchimp running until you’re sure.
“We use Butter instead of Mailchimp because it syncs with Planning Center so well and looks phenomenal.”
Your people sync. Your events don’t.
Mailchimp connects to Planning Center People, so your list stays current. It can’t see Registrations or your Calendar. Every event you send has to be typed in from scratch.
| Mailchimp | ||
|---|---|---|
Your events are already in Planning Center.
In Mailchimp you copy the date, time, location, and sign-up link into an empty block. In Butter you pick the event.
Fall RetreatFri, Oct 24 · Camp Willow
Fall Work DaySat, Oct 11
Men’s BreakfastSat, Oct 18
The sections already know what a church event is.
Date, time, place, and sign-up link, all in the right spots and already designed for a phone. In Mailchimp you build that out of empty blocks every week.
Same price as Mailchimp.
Matched at every list size. No setup fee, nothing held back for a higher tier.
FAQs
If yours isn’t here, email support@butterhq.com.
Do I have to cancel Mailchimp first?
No. Keep it running until you’re sure. Most churches run both for about a month.
Will my unsubscribes carry over?
They stay in Mailchimp, so export only your subscribed contacts and nobody who left gets added. Once you’re on Butter, anyone who unsubscribes stays unsubscribed. The Planning Center sync never adds them back.
Can I keep our old newsletters?
Those stay in Mailchimp. Butter starts with your next one. Send us your last newsletter and we’ll rebuild it in Butter, so you don’t start from a blank page.
How long does the switch take?
Under five minutes. Connect Planning Center and your people come straight in. Anyone who only signed up through Mailchimp, we’ll move over for you. Most churches send their first Butter newsletter the same day.
What if it doesn’t work out?
Cancel from your account any time. Your list is yours, and you can export it whenever you want.
Is Mailchimp free for churches?
Mailchimp’s free plan covers 250 contacts and 500 emails a month. A weekly newsletter to 250 people is about 1,000 emails a month, so most churches need a paid plan from the start. (Mailchimp’s pricing page, October 2026.)
Does Mailchimp give churches a nonprofit discount?
Mailchimp takes 15% off paid plans for verified 501(c)(3) organizations. Churches are tax-exempt automatically, and many never applied for an IRS determination letter. Check what Mailchimp will accept as proof before you count on the discount.
What does Butter cost?
From $20 a month for up to 500 contacts. Every plan includes unlimited sends and every feature. No nonprofit paperwork. See pricing.
Does Butter work with Planning Center?
Yes. It’s the only integration we build. Your People lists and your Calendar and Registrations events come straight across. If you use Planning Center’s Mailchimp sync today, here’s how the two compare.
