Mailchimp is a capable email tool. A lot of churches already know it, and Planning Center even points you there when a list gets large or a message needs more design than People can offer.
I still think many of those churches are doing extra work every week. I used to be the person who sent the newsletter, after about seven years on church staff, most of it in communications. Mailchimp could have my list. It could not see the church calendar. So I retyped dates, rooms, and sign-up links by hand.
Butter is the newsletter platform I wished I had then. It is built for churches on Planning Center. This post is a fair look at what Planning Center’s Mailchimp integration does well, where it stops, and when Butter is a better fit for the weekly newsletter. The longer product page is Mailchimp alternative for churches. The integration itself is explained, step by step, in how the Planning Center Mailchimp integration works.
What the Planning Center Mailchimp integration does well
Planning Center’s connection to Mailchimp is made to hand names over. It does that job clearly.
An organization administrator connects one Mailchimp account and picks one Mailchimp audience for the whole church. Each People list you sync becomes a tag, named after the list, inside that one audience. You can turn on a nightly re-sync so people who leave the list come off the tag overnight. Then you build and send the email in Mailchimp.
If your church already lives in Mailchimp, that is a reasonable setup. Stay with it if you rely on Mailchimp’s automated welcome series, you run A/B tests, you sell things through Mailchimp, or most of the people you email are not in Planning Center at all. I mean that. Switching for its own sake is a waste of a week.
I checked these details against Planning Center’s help center in October 2026, and I keep them on the integration page. If you use the integration, confirm the current steps in Planning Center’s own help, because products change.
Where that setup stops
None of these are bugs. The integration was built to move names into Mailchimp.
You get one Mailchimp account and one audience per Planning Center organization. Lists are synced one at a time, as tags, not as separate audiences.
A list refreshes once a night, and only if you turn on that list’s re-sync. If you forget the switch, the tag stays as it was the day you synced it.
The integration syncs lists from People. It does not bring over Calendar or Registrations events. The date, the room, the image, and the sign-up link still have to be typed into the email.
The email is built in Mailchimp’s general editor, which is made for every kind of business. An event block or a sermon section is something you design yourself, and often redesign the next week.
It carries first name, last name, and email. That is enough to say hello by name. It is not enough to fill an event section from Planning Center.
How Butter handles the same job
Butter’s only integration is Planning Center. Turn on People sync and every People list shows up as an audience. You pick one or several when you send. There is nothing to tag.
Butter checks Planning Center for changes about once an hour, and you can hit Sync now right before you send. Make a change in Planning Center and it updates in Butter.
Events come across too. In the email builder, I pick an event from Registrations or Calendar and it drops in with the date, time, place, image, and sign-up button. It is a copy, so I choose when to bring it in. I am not retyping the retreat every Thursday.
The sections are made for church mail: announcements, events, sermons, ways to give, a map, a plan-a-visit note. They are already designed for a phone. You can see them on the templates page, and in newsletter examples.
Butter only reads from Planning Center. It never writes back, and the sync never resubscribes someone who has opted out. Like the Mailchimp integration, it brings across first name, last name, and email, plus a profile photo. Other fields stay in Planning Center.
Butter does not try to replace everything Mailchimp can do. There are no automations here, and no Planning Center Groups. If those are the reason you opened Mailchimp this morning, stay there. If the job is a designed weekly newsletter, built from the people and events you already have, that is the work Butter is for.
Cost, and how a switch actually works
Butter starts at $20 a month for up to 500 people. Every plan includes unlimited sends, every section, unlimited teammates, and Planning Center sync. There is no setup fee. Details are on the pricing page.
You do not have to cancel Mailchimp first. Keep it running until you are sure. The trial is 14 days, no card required, and you can send real newsletters during those two weeks.
Unsubscribes should stay respected. Export only the people who are still subscribed in Mailchimp, so nobody who already left is added. Once someone unsubscribes in Butter, they stay unsubscribed. The Planning Center sync does not add them back.
Old newsletters stay in Mailchimp. Butter starts with your next one. If you want help matching the last email you sent, write to support@butterhq.com.
Before you compare prices, check Mailchimp’s current pricing against how often you send and how many people you email. Then look at Butter’s pricing next to whatever you are paying now.
If you want to try it this week
If Mailchimp is doing a job it was built for, keep it. If the weekly newsletter is a Planning Center export followed by a blank email, try Butter for 14 days. Connect Planning Center, bring this week’s events in, and send the next newsletter from the calendar you already have.
The companion pages, if you want more detail first, are switching from Mailchimp and how the Planning Center Mailchimp integration works.